NHL 2K11 Early Impressions

With a few days under the belt to give NHL 2K11 a run-through, I feel I’ve had enough time to draw up a few conclusions on the game (and the state of the franchise), thought – to be fair – I’ve yet to dive headfirst into the deeper modes (like franchise). My impressions are strictly based on exhibition gameplay (and a little online as well).
With that said, let’s get the show rolling. I’ll start with the positives…
1) Feature packed. When one looks at the state of Wii gaming as a whole, and especially Wii sports gaming, there isn’t a whole lot of depth there. NHL 2K11 is pretty loaded with features – this is the same 2K game you’ve seen on the current-gen consoles and not a Wii downgrade. Though if you’ve played NHL 2K10 on the Wii you might want to check out my number one complaint down below…
2) Road to the Cup. The biggest new feature utilizes your Mii and is a fun diversion (and can be more than that) for those who like the Mii angle. At the very least, it’s an addition to the same old mini rink and pond hockey we’ve seen year in and year out.
3) Graphics. This is a very sharp looking title on the Wii. It won’t blow you away if your used to playing PS3/Xbox 360 on your HD set, but in 480p, this game performs quite nicely.
4) Simple Gameplay. I have some issues with controls, but generally the game is easy to pick up and play. It does seem to cater more to the casual hockey fan in my opinion though.

OK, on to the bad…
1) Same ol’ same ol’. This is essentially the same gig that came out last year. I haven’t check this myself, but one 2K Sports forum user commented about the schedules in franchise being the same as last season. That’s uncalled for. I haven’t ran into that many bugs (have had players “freeze” into animations where all they do is spin around in place), but I’ve heard that many of the same ones as last year are back. Rosters seem ok in spots, but they are problematic (Huet as the starting goalie for the Blackhawks? Really?).
2) Online is a wasteland. I actually did get into a game yesterday after waiting only a couple minutes. The gameplay was smooth and effortless until a major slowdown midway through the second that essentially caused the session to disconnect. Being a ranked game, my opponent (who was up 1-0) didn’t receive a win. I wasn’t able to get into another game after that. I have signed up for a league, which filled up with 12 people. The league, called nhl2k11, seemed to be the only one filled as I write this. Only a handful of leagues have even been created.
3) Wonky controls. I hate readying myself for a one-timer only to pause while my player winds up for a point-blank slapshot – which, because of all the delay, he rarely ends up getting off anyway. I have found wrist-shots (and one-timers involving wrist-shots) to be quite problematic to pull off, maybe because they are tied to the same button. I have burned off a variety of goal scoring chances due to the game not knowing exactly what shot I was trying to do.
4) Impossible faceoffs. Maybe it’s just me, but you have to be ridiculously fast to win a faceoff, and even then it seems you end up, at best, in a scrum for the puck. I lost at least 85% of the faceoffs in every game I played.
5) Dull commentary. I know these guys work for real NHL organizations, but I’d hate for them to be calling games for my favorite team. It’s not the worst, but it just doesn’t standout, and half the fun of watching a hockey game is for the great commentary. Throw this one under No. 1 too, as it seems completely recycled from last year.
6) Gimmicky controls. Do I really need to pick up the puck on my stick when I deke, then 360 it into the net. Yeah, it’s not easy to pull off, but it’s still way easier than it would be in real life. In fact, I’ve never seen such a shot in real life…
Taken face value, with no regard for NHL 2K10 (or EA’s current series, and the upcoming NHL Slapshot for that matter), NHL 2K11 is a decent experience and emulates the game well. That’s always been the case for the series the past few years. It’s a pedestrian, but playable hockey game that will appeal to those who haven’t seen better, or don’t necesarrily care about online play (which EA’s game offers in droves). We’ve yet to see what EA offers with Slapshot though, so, for now, 2K11 remains the leader in the clubhouse on the Wii.




